Knicks might not win the NBA title, but they’re playing championship ball - The Athletic
Key keywords: New York Knicks, 2024 NBA Playoffs, Jalen Brunson, Tom Thibodeau, Madison Square Garden, Julius Randle, NBA Championship, Eastern Conference, defensive intensity
Even as the 2024 NBA Playoffs progress and pre-season title favorites like the Boston Celtics and Denver Nuggets remain atop most pundits’ power rankings, the New York Knicks have emerged as one of the most surprising, compelling stories of the postseason. For the first time in more than two decades, the Knicks are playing with the kind of grit, cohesion, and poise that defined championship-caliber teams of the franchise’s golden era, even if few analysts are ready to slot them as legitimate title favorites this year.
Head coach Tom Thibodeau, long maligned in some circles for his short rotation and rigid defensive schemes, has finally found a roster that fits his philosophy perfectly. Jalen Brunson, the Knicks’ undisputed floor general, has elevated his game to elite superstar status in the playoffs, averaging over 30 points and 7 assists per game through the first two rounds while routinely taking over in crunch time. Julius Randle, who faced heavy criticism for his inconsistent playoff performances in prior years, has bounced back as a dominant two-way force, averaging a double-double and locking down opposing forwards on the perimeter and in the paint. Role players including OG Anunoby, Josh Hart, and Donte DiVincenzo have also punched above their weight, stepping up with clutch shots, relentless rebounding, and tenacious perimeter defense whenever the team needs it most.
Madison Square Garden has been an impenetrable fortress for the team this postseason, with the Knicks winning every home game through the first two rounds in front of sellout crowds that have delivered some of the loudest, most electric atmospheres in recent NBA memory. The team’s defensive intensity has been their calling card: they rank top 3 in the playoffs in defensive rating, turnovers forced per game, and opponent field goal percentage in the paint, often wearing down higher-seeded teams over the course of 48 minutes.
Of course, significant barriers stand between the Knicks and a Larry O’Brien Trophy this year. The Boston Celtics, who finished with the best record in the Eastern Conference, boast a deeper, more experienced playoff roster and have beaten the Knicks twice in the regular season. If the Knicks advance to the Finals, they would likely face the defending champion Denver Nuggets, led by back-to-back MVP Nikola Jokic, who has proven almost unguardable in postseason play. But none of that takes away from what the Knicks have already accomplished this year. After years of front office missteps, losing seasons, and fan frustration, the franchise has finally built a sustainable, winning culture that can compete for titles for years to come. Even if they fall short this postseason, they have already won over the city of New York, restored pride to one of the most historic franchises in all of sports, and proven that they are playing championship-level basketball every time they take the floor.
Featured Comments
As a Knicks fan of 30 years, I haven’t felt this much pride in this team since the Patrick Ewing era. Even if we lose to the Celtics in the Eastern Conference Finals, none of us will be upset this year. Brunson is a once-in-a-generation franchise player, Thibs has built something real and lasting, and the future is brighter than it’s been in decades.
I’m a diehard Celtics fan but I have so much respect for what the Knicks are doing right now. Their defense is absolutely suffocating, Brunson is impossible to slow down even when you throw multiple defenders at him, and that Madison Square Garden crowd is a real sixth man. If we meet in the conference finals, it’s going to be an all-time classic series, no matter who comes out on top.
People sleeping on the Knicks as legitimate title contenders are making a huge mistake. Yeah, the Celtics and Nuggets are the obvious favorites, but this team has the grit, the elite coaching, and the consistent go-to scorer to pull off multiple upsets. We’ve seen far crazier things happen in the NBA Playoffs, and I wouldn’t count them out just yet.
What stands out to me most is how connected this Knicks team is. There’s no ego, everyone buys into their role, and they play for each other every single possession. That’s the exact kind of culture that wins championships, even if it takes them another year or two to get over the hump. This isn’t a flash in the pan success story.