Why Ashley Hinson's 'Save Our Bacon Act' Is Central to the 2024 US Farm Bill Negotiation Fight
Key keywords: Ashley Hinson, Save Our Bacon Act, 2024 US Farm Bill, US pork industry, Proposition 12, factory farming regulation, animal welfare mandates, small family hog farms, agricultural policy lobbying, SNAP benefits
As Congress races to pass the 2024 Farm Bill before the temporary extension of the 2018 legislation expires in September, a relatively niche proposal from Iowa Republican Representative Ashley Hinson has emerged as the biggest sticking point in bipartisan negotiations. Hinson, whose district is home to more than 4,000 hog operations that contribute $7.5 billion annually to Iowa’s economy, first introduced the Save Our Bacon Act in 2023 to roll back state-level animal welfare rules that apply to out-of-state pork producers, most notably California’s Proposition 12.
Passed by 63% of California voters in 2018, Proposition 12 requires all pork sold in the state to come from sows housed with enough space to stand, turn around, and lie down without touching enclosure walls, effectively banning the use of narrow gestation crates that have long been criticized by animal welfare groups. Hinson and pork industry advocates argue that the rule places an unfair, cost-prohibitive burden on producers across the country who sell to California’s $45 billion grocery market: small family hog farms, in particular, say they cannot afford the $150,000 to $300,000 in facility upgrades required to meet the standard, forcing many to either exit the market or pass 15% to 20% higher costs on to consumers nationwide.
The Save Our Bacon Act would bar states from imposing agricultural production standards on goods imported from other states, effectively invalidating Proposition 12 and blocking similar rules under consideration in 11 other blue states. House Republicans have made attaching the act to the Farm Bill a non-negotiable precondition for their support, with 112 GOP members signing a letter in June 2024 stating they will vote against any Farm Bill that does not include the provision.
Democratic lawmakers and White House officials, however, have pushed back hard, arguing the act overrides the will of state voters, sets a dangerous precedent for eroding state consumer protection authority, and prioritizes agribusiness profits over humane livestock treatment. The standoff threatens to derail the entire $1.5 trillion Farm Bill, which funds not only agricultural subsidies but also the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) that feeds 42 million low-income Americans, rural development grants, and disaster relief for farmers hit by extreme weather. If Congress fails to reach a compromise by September, critical programs will lapse, leading to projected 10% spikes in national pork prices, suspended SNAP benefits for 2 million households, and delayed relief for farmers recovering from this year’s Midwest droughts.
Featured Comments
As a third-generation small hog farmer in northeast Iowa, I can tell you the Save Our Bacon Act isn’t about cutting corners on animal care—it’s about survival. I can’t afford $220,000 to rebuild my sow barn just to comply with a California law that doesn’t even consider the welfare standards we already follow on my farm. If this doesn’t get into the Farm Bill, half the small producers in my county will be out of business by next spring, and only the giant corporate factory farms will be left.
This is a blatant giveaway to big agribusiness lobbies that have spent millions pushing this act. Proposition 12 was passed by California voters because we don’t want to buy pork from sows kept in crates so small they can’t turn around for their entire lives. The Save Our Bacon Act strips states of their right to set their own consumer protection rules, and forcing it into the Farm Bill is a cynical move that holds food assistance for millions of low-income families hostage to corporate greed.
This fight is a perfect microcosm of what’s broken with congressional policymaking right now. Both sides are dug in on a single industry issue while the entire Farm Bill hangs in the balance. If it lapses in September, we’re not just looking at higher pork prices—we’re looking at SNAP benefits getting cut for families struggling with food inflation, disaster relief getting delayed for corn and soybean farmers hit by this summer’s droughts, and a whole lot of avoidable pain for ordinary people on both sides of the debate.